Riddle me this: What’s the difference between Donald Trump and the novel coronavirus? Other than the fact that the virus doesn’t lie, discriminate or emit offensive tweets, not much.
If you were expecting a pithy one-liner, my sincere apologies. Alas, there is nothing funny about the destructive duality of Trump and this pandemic. Together, they are responsible for the most powerful and tenacious one-two punch ever leveled against our norms, values and way of life.
Not that long ago, most of us were living relatively stable lives. Sure, we had our problems: racism, misogyny, income inequality, climate change, among many others. We dealt with those matters mostly through elections, by voting for folks who share our values. Meanwhile, kids went to school and parents went to work. Weekends were for shopping, barbecuing and a movie. Summers were for vacation trips, crowded beaches, fairs and festivals. Despite our periodic frustrations with the government, we believed that our founders endowed us with a democracy inherently respectful of our rights, liberty and humanity.
Then along came Trump and the killer virus he tried to cover up. Suddenly, our relatively ordered lives, along with the norms and traditions that held us together, are nowhere to be found. Instead, we are on edge and out of sorts. Life seems upside down and inside out. Stuff we used to count on and take for granted has vanished. It feels like we are bobbing in a psychic sea of anomie and entropy, struggling to keep our heads above water.
Sociologists tell us that norms are essential to maintaining social order (here, here and here). They take the randomness out of everyday life by instilling in us a sense of predictability. Norms mean we don’t grab an item out of another customer’s grocery cart; we knock or ring a doorbell before entering someone’s house; and although we may not agree with our president’s politics, we assume he (and eventually “she”?) will protect us and our country from harm.
To be sure, norms change periodically as they adapt to evolving culture and technology. Think gay marriage, #metoo, not buying Twitter followers. For the most part, norm modifications gradually grow into acceptance. The problem comes when huge chunks of our normative lives are suddenly upended, leaving us without a trace of social equilibrium.
This is happening to us on two fronts. First, our president is obliterating every norm and symbol of our democracy, turning America from a beacon of hope into an unrecognizable cauldron of chaos and despair. Secondly, our own lives have been diminished and fractured by the contents of that very cauldron.
The crisis has been building for years. We probably should have seen it coming when we elected a man who boasted about sexually assaulting women, and labeled Mexican immigrants as rapists and drug dealers. Although we missed those signals, Trump handed us a gem of a clue when he had babies snatched from their mothers’ arms and put into cages on our southern border. Even then, as abhorrent as that behavior was, it was hard to imagine the normative evisceration that lay ahead.
Yet, day in and day out, this 45th president shreds one touchstone of decency after another. He traffics in racist putdowns. He affirms white supremacists. He threatens to jail political opponents. He lies constantly. He solicits foreign leaders to tamper with our elections. He hurls words like “dumb, stupid, terrible and dishonest” at those who disagree with him. The list is endless. Donald Trump has managed to discard every standard of presidential behavior that our country holds dear.
Like an addict falling deeper and deeper into the abyss of the bizarre and aberrant, this president’s decline is rapidly accelerating. More norms fall every day. We just learned from The Atlantic that the commander in chief refers to dead and wounded soldiers as “suckers” and “losers.” Thanks to journalist Bob Woodward, we now know that Trump deliberately lied to the American people when he said the novel coronavirus was nothing to worry about. He knew its lethality and did nothing to stop it.
There is so much more. He is:
- Pushing the postal service to screw up delivery of mail ballots.
- Supporting white supremacist and conspiracy theory groups.
- Encouraging armed right wing militias to take on Black Lives Matter protests.
- Using the Justice Department to defend him in a rape suit.
- Pressuring security analysts to doctor their reports to protect his political position.
The cumulative weight of all this norm-busting behavior not only adds to the anxiety of most Americans, it leaves us with the inescapable apprehension that our president will stop at nothing in serving his interests, regardless of the damage inflicted on the rest of us.
More directly, we feel the angst and pain from the normative destruction in our own lives. The pandemic, of course, would have torpedoed many of our daily norms, even under the best of leadership. But we had the worst. As a result, we’ve spent the past six months fighting over masks, social distancing, covid testing, school closings and Clorox injections. Our ultimate escape – a vaccine – is now in peril because of the fear that our president will push through a snake oil remedy just in time for the election.
As the number of cases and deaths continue to mount, much of our lives remain on hold. The rituals that connected us and filled life with meaning and richness now live only in our memories. We avoid family gatherings. We don’t hug anymore. We wait to bury the dead, and then limit the number who can attend a funeral. We avoid stores, and burden minimum wage workers to get us our supplies. We don’t look forward to a lot because we have no idea when this nightmare will end.
Although this dystopian saga has depleted our supply of norms, it has been rich in the production of ironies, the biggest of which is this: Donald J. Trump entered our lives by promising to Make America Great Again. He damn near destroyed it.
Now comes Joe Biden, our only shot at – in the words of Langston Hughes – “Making America, America again.”
Another one out of the park, B. I’ll be sharing.
A great piece, Bruce. I think we are living in a neutral zone: the place between the past and an unknown future. An uncomfortable place to say the least. Everything is possible in the neutral zone. The choices are clear: evolve America or destroy it. Trump’s base prefers destruction. The rest of us wants American to evolve into a better nation. All we have to do is vote.
Take all of the above as given, wrap it in a cloud of noxious air that further isolates you from any visible community, stir in a storm of rumors about an antifa plot to start wildfires across the state and what do you get. The line-up I saw of men waiting to get in to the gun shop ( limiting access due to covid – no masks in sight) for ammo and guns. Ammo is apparently in short supply.
Perfectly said, Bridget!
Thanks Bruce. Your blogs help me keep my sanity during this reign of terror. The trump damage will take a long time to clean up. I hope we can endure, and God help us if there is another 4 years. What this says about the cult that supports him is absolutely frightening. Keep writing!